The Problems With Being Called “Cute”: Deconstructing A Diminutive Stereotype

by: Mimi  Nguyen

“You’re so cute! You’re like a baby seal covered in oil.”

My roommate said this to me as I washed a zip lock bag in our sink and explained how we should reuse plastic products. His words shocked me. The image of an oil slick seal cub with my crying face came to mind. I liked being called cute but I did not like being compared to an infant animal made helpless. To my roommate, these descriptions are synonymous. The word “cute” took on a whole new meaning and I realized it has always had multiple definitions and implications, some of which are tragically negative and insulting. I looked at my roommate’s smiling face, realized he was joking, and laughed at his comment but remained speechless.

People have told me I am “cute” all my life and even though I understand the description as a compliment, I’m not sure I want to be described this way anymore. The Pulitzer Prize winning poet Mary Oliver especially hates the word “cute” when used to describe nature’s animals and plants, but what she says can also be applied to people. “Such words – “cute,” “charming,” “adorable” – miss the mark, for what is perceived of in this way is stripped of dignity, and authority. What is cute is entertainment, and replaceable. The words lead us and we follow: what is cute is diminutive, it is powerless, it is capturable, it is trainable, it is ours. It is all a mistake. […] We live, I am sure of this, in the same country, in the same household, and our burning comes from the same lamp. We are all wild, valorous, amazing. We are, none of us, cute.”[1]

When most people call me “cute” I think they are describing my short four feet eleven inches of stature, my bubbly personality, and my Asian heritage. It is often difficult to detach myself from the clichéd images of wide eyed Korean pop stars, Japanese school girls, and giggly anime characters. I’m Vietnamese, but I was born in Long Beach, California, never listen to Korean pop, never worn a Japanese school uniform and never had animated stars and hearts jump from my eyes. Despite these facts, I’m still grouped into the same “cute” category as these caricatures and this disturbs me because the more I think about it, the more I’m convinced these stock images of Asian women come from one primary stereotype – the “China Doll.”

The “China Doll” is characterized as a docile woman with childlike qualities such as submissiveness and reverence. Her opposite is the “Dragon Lady,” a domineering temptress with a violent streak. Television and cinema commonly use one of these two characterizations for their Asian female lead – think Lucy Liu in Ally McBeal or Ziyi Zhang in Memoirs of a Geisha. I’ll leave “Dragon Ladies” for another discussion, but “China Dolls” definitely fall under the sphere of “cute.” The obedient nature associated with “China Dolls” is exactly what Oliver means when she explains how “cute” is synonymous with “powerless,” “capturable,” and “trainable.” The word “China” brings to mind several definitions and images, the most obvious is the country – which implicates ethnic otherness or third world inferiority – but the first image in my mind is the translucent ceramic material used to make fine dishware and – more importantly – children’s dolls. Already connecting “China Dolls” with a breakable material, we are encouraged further to think of these women as lifeless and bendable playthings. Dolls that are “powerless” and “trainable.” Objects.

Of course, “cute” is used to describe other women too, and not just petite Asians. Red heads, waitresses, grandmothers. We even use “cute” to describe things that aren’t human. Puppies are cute. Fresh manicures are cute. New shoes are cute. The word has become so overused it has lost all significant meaning. So, when we describe people as “cute,” do they become as banal and insignificant as the word?

I’m not sure of this because my “cuteness” had definitely proved advantageous over the years. When a stranger has an extra movie ticket, coffee, or even plates of food, I’m usually the lucky recipient of their bounty. People tend to be more comfortable approaching me about directions or clarification than the other taller, whiter, women around me. Incidentally, the majority of my friends are Caucasian, which is a result of my predominately white undergraduate and graduate programs; tack that on for another later discussion.

But even as I write this rant it is painfully obvious to me that I too, misuse the word. For a short time I had an online dating profile and the way I described myself was “A cute Asian girl with hot pink highlights.” The strange thing is I don’t believe myself when I write “I’m cute,” it just seemed like the easiest and fastest way to introduce my personality on the page. So many friends, family members, and acquaintances have told me I am this word, and I use it. It’s a habit. It’s completely lazy and that’s why “cute” has lost all significant meaning. Those who overuse the adjective lack the motivation to think of a more accurate description which ultimately becomes an act of apathy or disrespect.

Perhaps it’s time I take responsibility for my treatment of the English language. The vocabulary at my disposal provides all the tools for better care. How a group of people – a country – uses its words greatly reflects the social and cultural awareness of the speakers. Worst case scenario is sounding pretentious, but the best case scenario could be revolutionary in the way we treat and understand each other. The next time my roommate calls me “cute,” I’ll do my best impression of Inigo Montoya from The Princess Bride, say, “You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means,” and suggest another adjective such as resplendent, ingenious, sassy, diligent, clever, approachable, rapturous, spirited, irreplaceable…

Tien (Mimi) Nguyen is a former TriQuarterly Online Art Director, and nonfiction and fiction editor. She is currently pursuing an MFA in creative nonfiction at Northwestern University. She contributes regularly to TriQuarterly Online and has worked for The Long Beach Press-TelegramRunes Literary Magazine and The Iowa Review.


[1] Oliver, Mary. Blue Pastures. Orlando: Harcourt, Inc. 1995. p92-93.

Advertisements

10 responses to “The Problems With Being Called “Cute”: Deconstructing A Diminutive Stereotype

  1. YES. Thank you for spelling out exactly the issues with this word. People use it to describe me all of the time. Folks have told me “when they say cute they really mean hot/intelligent/etc.” but why not just say that instead?

  2. I had a falling out with someone when they called something I did cute today. I get called it a lot and being a guy, it feels “strange”. I don’t think I’m cute in the slightest: I have a beard, I’m 6’2″ and a deepish voice and yet it’s a common descriptor for me and my “actions” (ie. when I’m trying to be caring and/or romantic).

    By calling me cute, I feel like I’m not being taken seriously and being 22 also, it goes hand in hand with being called “young” as another common descriptor. While I may be younger than most adults, I am still an adult and have been for 4 years now so I’d just like to be seen as a man instead of a “cute young boy”.

  3. OMG its soooooooo true that asian girls are catagorised into the cute, china doll section. Lots of my non-asian friends have commented that i look like a “doll” or “one of those Japanese cartoons, those mangas”. and once, this school friend commented on one of my pictures that i look like a “china doll”. my god i felt like bashing my head! she meant it in a nice way (i asked her) but i don’t WANT to be categorised into the cute section–i think im just average and normal.

  4. Pingback: The Perils of Not Being “Cute”: A Response to “Deconstructing a Diminuitive Stereotype” « In Our Words·

  5. I’m tall, female and Caucasian and people call me cute. I don’t know why. I’m cynical and tend to get people mad because I actually have a brain (wow, amazing, right?). Maybe they’re saying that to cut me down, or they really think that being cold and cynical is cute. Creeps.

  6. Thanks so much for this blog!! I absolutely distaste the word and as much as I try and explain to my boyfriend that I being called cute and adorable belittles me in a way. I make grammar mistakes in my English when I speak and though he, or his friends see it as cute, for me is a little bit racist, if you know what I mean. Cheers again for this and take care!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s